I've been using Sky Player on WMC7 for a few days now and feel it's worthy of some comments...for the unaware, Sky Player is an app that Microsoft kindly downloaded to your Media Center, to provide you with some extra TV channels & functionality (whether you wanted it or not!).
There have been many comments on the forums about 'how do I remove this Sky Player thing' and 'I don't want this, my investment in Media Center is why I don't have a Sky sub' etc but if you look at as an exercise in Silverlight, it seems to be pretty versatile on the face of it.
Now, I'm no Flash expert (rightly or wrongly I've considered Silverlight to be a bit of tech to go against Flash), but I'm not sure that Flash is able to regulate it's quality depending on your bandwidth. If it did/was, I'm sure the original boo.com wouldn't've folded.
So, with that in mind, Sky Player running from my 10 Mb Virgin Media connection, watching Sky Sports News, on it's high quality setting at 1.8 (out of 2) the quality still seems a bit like watching Friends on Friends+1. Is it like a reduced frame rate or something? Interestingly enough, the adverts seem fine though, as good as good SD. Clearly, live encoding at high quality is still short of the mark: compared to the low quality setting, it looks like a MUX4 transmission.
Watching PNE v Hull on Sky Player at low quality, looks like a dodgy internet stream from Iraq or something. Whacking it up to high yields better results, but it's frame rate reduction and subsequent jerkiness leaves me thinking whether or not I'm going to switch on Black Ops or not. Even a couple of shots of Mother's Ruin don't appear to have sorted out the jerkiness. Again, pre-rendered stuff is perfect. Looks great.
Live, high speed sports like football & rugby (not F1!) really test the tech these days; watching live Sky Sports 1 via Sky Player (on my top drawer Panasonic), is like watching broadcast Sky Sports on my old cheap LCD: it couldn't keep up.
Anyway, the audio is flawless, as is the non live content and even the info overlay looks great; it wouldn't surprise me if the next version of WMC has the Sky Player, or similar, overlay. But I'd expect that by then they'd've integrated the Sky Player EPG fully with the remote. While I can bring up the programme info by pressing 'i', and see what is on the other channels right now, I cannot see what is coming up next, unless I grab the mouse - this is not doing anything for the GAF or WAF. Also while I'm at it, there are no recording, or pause/resume functions available. All we're getting is straight feed. Annoying to say the least if you're watching a film and you're suddenly tired half way through. You'll have to resume from the start...
Sky are really protective of their IP, which I have no problem with, but it oversteps the mark when I'm only allowed certain content on certain a PC; it's almost as if I have to have a per-user license for TV when Sky are involved. That extends to Sky multi-room to a certain extent too, IIRC. It should be done on IP address. I'm sure there's more to this than I understand, but it seems overly complicated.
It's an interesting package, I'm sure the take up would be really high if the price was lower. I don't think that they'd run the risk of current subscribers getting the hump; if that was the case they'd all build a media center...and I just don't think this is going to happen, it's too easy to get a Sky or Virgin TV sub - plus most other halves are not happy with PCs in the living room - I'm fortunate; my girlfriend thinks its brilliant; all of our music, pix, films & TV all in one place.
I've been using Sky Player on WMC7 for a few days now and feel it's worthy of some comments...for the unaware, Sky Player is an app that Microsoft kindly downloaded to your Media Center, to provide you with some extra TV channels & functionality (whether you wanted it or not!).
There have been many comments on the forums about 'how do I remove this Sky Player thing' and 'I don't want this, my investment in Media Center is why I don't have a Sky sub' etc but if you look at as an exercise in Silverlight, it seems to be pretty versatile on the face of it.
Now, I'm no Flash expert (rightly or wrongly I've considered Silverlight to be a bit of tech to go against Flash), but I'm not sure that Flash is able to regulate it's quality depending on your bandwidth. If it did/was, I'm sure the original boo.com wouldn't've folded.
So, with that in mind, Sky Player running from my 10 Mb Virgin Media connection, watching Sky Sports News, on it's high quality setting at 1.8 (out of 2) the quality still seems a bit like watching Friends on Friends+1. Is it like a reduced frame rate or something? Interestingly enough, the adverts seem fine though, as good as good SD. Clearly, live encoding at high quality is still short of the mark: compared to the low quality setting, it looks like a MUX4 transmission.
Watching PNE v Hull on Sky Player at low quality, looks like a dodgy internet stream from Iraq or something. Whacking it up to high yields better results, but it's frame rate reduction and subsequent jerkiness leaves me thinking whether or not I'm going to switch on Black Ops or not. Even a couple of shots of Mother's Ruin don't appear to have sorted out the jerkiness. Again, pre-rendered stuff is perfect. Looks great.
Live, high speed sports like football & rugby (not F1!) really test the tech these days; watching live Sky Sports 1 via Sky Player (on my top drawer Panasonic), is like watching broadcast Sky Sports on my old cheap LCD: it couldn't keep up.
Anyway, the audio is flawless, as is the non live content and even the info overlay looks great; it wouldn't surprise me if the next version of WMC has the Sky Player, or similar, overlay. But I'd expect that by then they'd've integrated the Sky Player EPG fully with the remote. While I can bring up the programme info by pressing 'i', and see what is on the other channels right now, I cannot see what is coming up next, unless I grab the mouse - this is not doing anything for the GAF or WAF. Also while I'm at it, there are no recording, or pause/resume functions available. All we're getting is straight feed. Annoying to say the least if you're watching a film and you're suddenly tired half way through. You'll have to resume from the start...
Sky are really protective of their IP, which I have no problem with, but it oversteps the mark when I'm only allowed certain content on certain a PC; it's almost as if I have to have a per-user license for TV when Sky are involved. That extends to Sky multi-room to a certain extent too, IIRC. It should be done on IP address. I'm sure there's more to this than I understand, but it seems overly complicated.
It's an interesting package, I'm sure the take up would be really high if the price was lower. I don't think that they'd run the risk of current subscribers getting the hump; if that was the case they'd all build a media center...and I just don't think this is going to happen, it's too easy to get a Sky or Virgin TV sub - plus most other halves are not happy with PCs in the living room - I'm fortunate; my girlfriend thinks its brilliant; all of our music, pix, films & TV all in one place.
BTW, despite threatening to go over to the PS3, I've not played Black Ops yet, I had to wait for the PS3 to finish updating, for 3D Blu-Ray no less.